Who is complaining?

CFPB file to

Who is complaining about FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC.?

In the CFPB database since
2012
Main product category
“Bank account or service”
Newest complaint on file

When looking at complaint volume about a company or product, consider company size and/or market share. For example, companies with more customers may have more complaints than companies with fewer customers.

the complaint process does not verify the allegations in each consumer’s complaint narrative, nor can it, as a practical matter.

The CFPB complaint process does not verify the allegations in each consumer’s complaint narrative. This site shows no complaint narrative. A complaint is a consumer’s account of a problem. It is not a finding against the company.

The 12-month count ends on . Read the response categories and their denominators.

The CFPB database holds 504 complaints about FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. The CFPB received them from 26 Mar 2012 to 1 Mar 2017. The CFPB received no complaint about the company in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026.

FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. could not be matched by name to a single institution in the FDIC, NCUA or HMDA files. Thus this site cannot set the count of the company against its size. A company with more customers may have more complaints than a company with fewer customers.

In all years on file, 58.1% of the complaints have the CFPB product category Bank account or service. Consumers selected the issue Account opening, closing, or management for 24.8% of the complaints.

In all years on file, the company response was Closed with explanation for 72.6% of the complaints. It was Closed with monetary relief for 14.5%. It was Closed with non-monetary relief for 9.5%. It was Closed without relief for 1.2%. It was Closed with relief for 1%. It was Untimely response for 0.6%. It was Closed for 0.6%. The field Timely response? is Yes for 97% of the responses.

Official pages of the CFPB

What changed since the last update?

The record holds no change for this company.

September 2026
0
October 2026
0

The figures are complaints received in the month. October 2026 is the last closed month. The record holds a change of 5 complaints and 20 percent or more. Updates and changes

What are the complaints about?

A consumer selects the product and the issue on the CFPB form. The labels are the words of the CFPB. A label shows the selection of the consumer. It does not show what a company did. Figures: in all years on file.

Complaints about FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. by CFPB product category, in all years on file
Product (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Bank account or service29358.1%
Mortgage10320.4%
Credit card6412.7%
Consumer Loan387.5%
Debt collection61.2%
Complaints about FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. by CFPB issue, in all years on file
Issue (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Account opening, closing, or management12524.8%
Deposits and withdrawals7514.9%
Problems caused by my funds being low5811.5%
Loan servicing, payments, escrow account397.7%
Loan modification,collection,foreclosure346.7%
Using a debit or ATM card224.4%
Application, originator, mortgage broker193.8%
Billing disputes132.6%
Making/receiving payments, sending money132.6%
Managing the loan or lease132.6%
Other CFPB issue categories9318.5%
Bank account or service: issues and sub-products

293 complaints in all years on file, 58.1% of the complaints about this company.

FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., “Bank account or service”: complaints by CFPB issue, in all years on file
Issue (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Account opening, closing, or management12542.7%
Deposits and withdrawals7525.6%
Problems caused by my funds being low5819.8%
Using a debit or ATM card227.5%
Making/receiving payments, sending money134.4%
FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., “Bank account or service”: complaints by CFPB sub-product, in all years on file
Sub-product (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Checking account22075.1%
Other bank product/service3511.9%
(CD) Certificate of deposit186.1%
Savings account175.8%
Cashing a check without an account31%
Mortgage: issues and sub-products

103 complaints in all years on file, 20.4% of the complaints about this company.

FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., “Mortgage”: complaints by CFPB issue, in all years on file
Issue (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Loan servicing, payments, escrow account3937.9%
Loan modification,collection,foreclosure3433%
Application, originator, mortgage broker1918.4%
Credit decision / Underwriting65.8%
Settlement process and costs32.9%
Other CFPB issue categories21.9%
FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., “Mortgage”: complaints by CFPB sub-product, in all years on file
Sub-product (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Other mortgage5553.4%
Conventional fixed mortgage2120.4%
Home equity loan or line of credit1918.4%
Conventional adjustable mortgage (ARM)43.9%
FHA mortgage43.9%
Credit card: issues and sub-products

64 complaints in all years on file, 12.7% of the complaints about this company.

FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., “Credit card”: complaints by CFPB issue, in all years on file
Issue (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Billing disputes1320.3%
Identity theft / Fraud / Embezzlement1117.2%
Billing statement46.3%
Other46.3%
Customer service / Customer relations34.7%
Other CFPB issue categories2945.3%
FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., “Credit card”: complaints by CFPB sub-product, in all years on file
Sub-product (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Other or no sub-product recorded64100%
Consumer Loan: issues and sub-products

38 complaints in all years on file, 7.5% of the complaints about this company.

FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., “Consumer Loan”: complaints by CFPB issue, in all years on file
Issue (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Managing the loan or lease1334.2%
Problems when you are unable to pay821.1%
Managing the line of credit821.1%
Shopping for a loan or lease410.5%
Taking out the loan or lease37.9%
Other CFPB issue categories25.3%
FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., “Consumer Loan”: complaints by CFPB sub-product, in all years on file
Sub-product (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Vehicle loan2155.3%
Personal line of credit1334.2%
Installment loan410.5%

How did the company respond?

The company selects one response category for each complaint. The categories are the words of the CFPB. Figures: in all years on file.

Company response to consumer: FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., in all years on file
Company response to consumer (CFPB category)ComplaintsShare
Closed with explanation36672.6%
Closed with monetary relief7314.5%
Closed with non-monetary relief489.5%
Closed without relief61.2%
Closed with relief51%
Untimely response30.6%
Closed30.6%
Responses of FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. beside its peers and all companies
MeasureThis companyAll companies
Timely response: Yes97%99.6%
Closed with monetary relief or with non-monetary relief25%30.8%
Closed with monetary relief14.5%0.5%

The CFPB file has no “Consumer disputed?” field now. The CFPB stopped that field in April 2017.

How many complaints did the CFPB receive in each month?

The CFPB received no complaint about this company in the last 24 months. The newest complaint on file has the date 1 Mar 2017.

Complaints in each year
Complaints about FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. in each calendar year
YearComplaints
20172
201689
201594
201492
2013103
2012124

How large is the company?

Public size measure
No public size measure This company could not be matched by name to a single institution in the FDIC, NCUA or HMDA files. Thus this site cannot set the count against the size of the company.

Peer companies are not the same size. A count without a size measure does not show which company has more complaints for each customer. The median for size shows only when five or more peers have the same kind of size measure. Why counts need denominators

From which states do the complaints come?

Complaints about FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. by the state of the consumer, in all years on file
State (as the consumer gave it)ComplaintsShare
New York26452.4%
Pennsylvania10921.6%
Connecticut6112.1%
Massachusetts132.6%
New Jersey112.2%
California91.8%
Florida40.8%
Ohio30.6%
Maine20.4%
Georgia20.4%
Arizona20.4%
Nevada20.4%

The table shows 12 of the 25 places with one or more complaints in all years on file. It selects the places with the largest counts. The places are the 50 states and the District of Columbia. The counts follow the population of a state and the places where the company does business.

Where can you submit a complaint or see the CFPB records?

Each link goes to consumerfinance.gov and opens in a new tab. Links checked on .

How do you cite this page?

Who Is Complaining. “Who is complaining about FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC.?”. Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Consumer Complaint Database, complaints received through 16 Nov 2026. https://whoiscomplaining.com/company/first-niagara-financial-group-inc/

The address of this page does not change.

Where do the figures come from?

Source
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Consumer Complaint Database, bulk file. Search the CFPB database
File read on
Complaints received through
Fields used
Company, product, sub-product, issue, state, dates, company response, timely response. This site does not read, keep or show the text of a complaint.
Open months
The CFPB publishes a complaint when the company responds, or after 15 days. Thus the newest two to three weeks are not complete.
Size files
FDIC BankFind (30 Jun 2026), NCUA call reports (30 Jun 2026), HMDA transmittal sheet (2025), Census Bureau population estimates (2025).
Company name
The name is as the CFPB publishes it.
Size match
No size measure: the company could not be matched by name to a single institution in the FDIC, NCUA or HMDA files.

More questions

How many complaints arrived in the last 30 days and the last 90 days?
0 complaints about FIRST NIAGARA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. arrived in the 30 days to 16 Nov 2026. 0 complaints arrived in the 90 days to 16 Nov 2026. The CFPB publishes a complaint when the company responds or after 15 days. Thus the counts of the newest weeks can still increase.
What share of the closed complaints ended with relief?
Of the closed complaints in all years on file, 25% are Closed with monetary relief or Closed with non-monetary relief. 14.5% of all the complaints in the period are Closed with monetary relief.
In which states do the consumers live?
Consumers in New York sent 52.4% of the complaints in all years on file. Consumers in Pennsylvania sent 21.6% of the complaints in all years on file. Consumers in Connecticut sent 12.1% of the complaints in all years on file. The complaints come from 25 of the 50 states and the District of Columbia.
Which other issues did consumers select in all years on file?
Consumers selected the issue Deposits and withdrawals for 14.9% of the complaints. Consumers selected the issue Problems caused by my funds being low for 11.5% of the complaints.