Who is complaining?

CFPB file to

Why complaint counts need denominators

The CFPB asks readers to consider the size of a company. It says this on its database page.

When looking at complaint volume about a company or product, consider company size and/or market share. For example, companies with more customers may have more complaints than companies with fewer customers.

Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Consumer Complaint Database, copied on .

A denominator is a number that you divide a count by. For complaints, the best denominator would be customers or accounts. No public file gives it for every company.

An example with invented numbers

These numbers are not real. They belong to no company. Two banks have these figures for one year.

Two invented banks: customers, complaints and complaints for each 100,000 customers
BankCustomersComplaintsFor each 100,000 customers
Bank A10,000,0005,00050
Bank B100,000200200

Bank A has 25 times the complaints of Bank B. It has 100 times the customers.

For each 100,000 customers, Bank A has 50 complaints and Bank B has 200. The raw counts and the per-customer figures lead to different readings.

A figure for each customer is still not a verdict. It does not show what either bank did.

The size measures that exist

Three public files give a size measure for some companies. The site matches a company to a file by name.

The size measures that this site uses, with the companies matched in this build
MeasureAgencyCompanies matched
Total assets of a bankFDIC89
Total assets of a credit unionNCUA19
Records of a mortgage lenderFFIEC, HMDA42

Limits of each measure

  • Assets are not customers. A bank with a large card business has more customers for each dollar of assets than a commercial bank. Compare similar companies.
  • A holding company does more than banking. When the main business of a group is outside its insured bank, bank assets understate its size. Each company page names the institutions that it counted.
  • HMDA counts new lending. It does not count the loans that a servicer handles for others. A servicer gets no HMDA rate on this site.
  • Most companies have no public measure. 1,224 of the 1,374 listed companies (89.1%) could not be matched by name to a single institution in the FDIC, NCUA or HMDA files. Their pages say so. The words describe the data, not the company.

The matching rules are on the methodology page.

Last checked against the CFPB pages: .