Who is complaining?

CFPB file to

Who is complaining about Fay Servicing, LLC?

In the CFPB database since
2012
Main product category
“Mortgage”
Newest complaint on file

When looking at complaint volume about a company or product, consider company size and/or market share. For example, companies with more customers may have more complaints than companies with fewer customers.

the complaint process does not verify the allegations in each consumer’s complaint narrative, nor can it, as a practical matter.

The CFPB complaint process does not verify the allegations in each consumer’s complaint narrative. This site shows no complaint narrative. A complaint is a consumer’s account of a problem. It is not a finding against the company.

The 12-month count ends on . Read the response categories and their denominators.

The CFPB received 392 complaints about Fay Servicing, LLC in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026. It received 501 complaints about the company in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2025. Since 2012 the database holds 4,082 complaints about the company.

HMDA does not measure the loans that a servicer handles. It counts the applications and loans that a lender reports each year. Thus this site shows no per-size rate for this company. A company with more customers may have more complaints than a company with fewer customers.

In the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026, 87.5% of the complaints have the CFPB product category Mortgage. Consumers selected the issue Trouble during payment process for 43.6% of the complaints.

In the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026, the company response was Closed with explanation for 98.7% of the complaints. It was In progress for 1.3%. The field Timely response? is Yes for 99.7% of the responses. The median share for the 78 companies with the main category Mortgage is 100%.

The median company with the main category Mortgage received 88 complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026.

Compared with the 12 months to 16 Nov 2025, the count of complaints about the company changed by -22%. In the same comparison, the count of all complaints changed by +42%. The product category Mortgage is 87.5% of the complaints about the company and 0.5% of all complaints.

Official pages of the CFPB

What changed since the last update?

The record holds no change for this company.

September 2026
34
October 2026
32

The figures are complaints received in the month. October 2026 is the last closed month. The record holds a change of 5 complaints and 20 percent or more. Updates and changes

What are the complaints about?

A consumer selects the product and the issue on the CFPB form. The labels are the words of the CFPB. A label shows the selection of the consumer. It does not show what a company did. Figures: in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026.

Complaints about Fay Servicing, LLC by CFPB product category, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
Product (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Mortgage34387.5%
Credit reporting or other personal consumer reports338.4%
Debt collection123.1%
Money transfer, virtual currency, or money service20.5%
Payday loan, title loan, personal loan, or advance loan10.3%
Vehicle loan or lease10.3%
Complaints about Fay Servicing, LLC by CFPB issue, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
Issue (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Trouble during payment process17143.6%
Struggling to pay mortgage12832.7%
Incorrect information on your report348.7%
Closing on a mortgage194.8%
Problem with a company's investigation into an existing problem133.3%
Applying for a mortgage or refinancing an existing mortgage82%
Attempts to collect debt not owed61.5%
False statements or representation41%
Improper use of your report20.5%
Took or threatened to take negative or legal action20.5%
Other CFPB issue categories51.3%
Mortgage: issues and sub-products

343 complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026, 87.5% of the complaints about this company. 433 complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2025. Of the closed complaints, 0% have a response with relief. 99.7% of the responses were timely.

Fay Servicing, LLC, “Mortgage”: complaints by CFPB issue, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
Issue (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Trouble during payment process17149.9%
Struggling to pay mortgage12837.3%
Closing on a mortgage195.5%
Incorrect information on your report82.3%
Applying for a mortgage or refinancing an existing mortgage82.3%
Other CFPB issue categories92.6%
Fay Servicing, LLC, “Mortgage”: complaints by CFPB sub-product, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
Sub-product (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Conventional home mortgage24270.6%
FHA mortgage5014.6%
Other type of mortgage216.1%
Home equity loan or line of credit (HELOC)185.2%
VA mortgage92.6%
Other or no sub-product recorded30.9%
Credit reporting or other personal consumer reports: issues and sub-products

33 complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026, 8.4% of the complaints about this company. 36 complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2025. Of the closed complaints, 0% have a response with relief. 100% of the responses were timely.

Fay Servicing, LLC, “Credit reporting or other personal consumer reports”: complaints by CFPB issue, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
Issue (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Incorrect information on your report2575.8%
Problem with a company's investigation into an existing problem824.2%
Fay Servicing, LLC, “Credit reporting or other personal consumer reports”: complaints by CFPB sub-product, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
Sub-product (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Credit reporting33100%
Debt collection: issues and sub-products

12 complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026, 3.1% of the complaints about this company. 24 complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2025. Of the closed complaints, 0% have a response with relief. 100% of the responses were timely.

Fay Servicing, LLC, “Debt collection”: complaints by CFPB issue, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
Issue (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Attempts to collect debt not owed650%
False statements or representation433.3%
Took or threatened to take negative or legal action216.7%
Fay Servicing, LLC, “Debt collection”: complaints by CFPB sub-product, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
Sub-product (CFPB label)ComplaintsShare
Mortgage debt975%
I do not know325%

How did the company respond?

The company selects one response category for each complaint. The categories are the words of the CFPB. Figures: in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026.

Company response to consumer: Fay Servicing, LLC, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
Company response to consumer (CFPB category)ComplaintsShare
Closed with explanation38798.7%
In progress51.3%
Responses of Fay Servicing, LLC beside its peers and all companies
MeasureThis companyMedian of 78 peersAll companies
Timely response: Yes99.7%100%99.6%
Closed with monetary relief or with non-monetary relief0%0%30.8%
Closed with monetary relief0%no figure0.5%

Peers are the 78 companies on this site with the main category “Mortgage” and 20 or more complaints in the last 12 months.

The CFPB file has no “Consumer disputed?” field now. The CFPB stopped that field in April 2017.

How many complaints did the CFPB receive in each month?

Complaints about Fay Servicing, LLC that the CFPB received in each of the last 24 months

Closed monthOpen monthA month is closed 15 days after its last day. The count of an open month can still increase. The last closed month is October 2026.

The counts as a table
Complaints about Fay Servicing, LLC that the CFPB received in each of the last 24 months
MonthComplaintsMonth status
November 20260open
October 202632closed
September 202634closed
August 202641closed
July 202633closed
June 202634closed
May 202623closed
April 202633closed
March 202637closed
February 202635closed
January 202628closed
December 202543closed
November 202532closed
October 202540closed
September 202530closed
August 202546closed
July 202553closed
June 202532closed
May 202548closed
April 202548closed
March 202543closed
February 202543closed
January 202548closed
December 202439closed
Complaints in each year
Complaints about Fay Servicing, LLC in each calendar year
YearComplaints
2026 (open year)330
2025506
2024446
2023353
2022395
2021355
2020321
2019258
2018292
2017320
2016209
2015168
201496
201330
20123

How large is the company?

Public size measure
No public size measure HMDA does not measure the loans that a servicer handles. It counts the applications and loans that a lender reports each year. Thus this site shows no per-size rate for this company.
Counts of Fay Servicing, LLC beside its peers
MeasureThis companyMedian of 78 peersAll companies
Complaints, last 12 months392887,279,620
Change from the 12 months before-22%47%42%

Peer companies are not the same size. A count without a size measure does not show which company has more complaints for each customer. The median for size shows only when five or more peers have the same kind of size measure. Why counts need denominators

From which states do the complaints come?

Complaints about Fay Servicing, LLC by the state of the consumer, in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026
State (as the consumer gave it)ComplaintsShare
New York4712%
Texas4210.7%
California4210.7%
Florida369.2%
New Jersey246.1%
Maryland215.4%
Georgia174.3%
Ohio164.1%
Massachusetts164.1%
Tennessee112.8%
Pennsylvania92.3%
Illinois92.3%

The table shows 12 of the 42 places with one or more complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026. It selects the places with the largest counts. The places are the 50 states and the District of Columbia. The counts follow the population of a state and the places where the company does business.

Which other companies have the same main category?

This list is for navigation. It is in the order of the names. The companies have the main category Mortgage and a count of complaints near the count of this company.

Where can you submit a complaint or see the CFPB records?

Each link goes to consumerfinance.gov and opens in a new tab. Links checked on .

How do you cite this page?

Who Is Complaining. “Who is complaining about Fay Servicing, LLC?”. Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Consumer Complaint Database, complaints received through 16 Nov 2026. https://whoiscomplaining.com/company/fay-servicing-llc/

The address of this page does not change.

Where do the figures come from?

Source
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Consumer Complaint Database, bulk file. Search the CFPB database
File read on
Complaints received through
Fields used
Company, product, sub-product, issue, state, dates, company response, timely response. This site does not read, keep or show the text of a complaint.
Open months
The CFPB publishes a complaint when the company responds, or after 15 days. Thus the newest two to three weeks are not complete.
Size files
FDIC BankFind (30 Jun 2026), NCUA call reports (30 Jun 2026), HMDA transmittal sheet (2025), Census Bureau population estimates (2025).
Company name
The name is as the CFPB publishes it.
Size match
No size measure: the company could not be matched by name to a single institution in the FDIC, NCUA or HMDA files. HMDA does not measure the loans that a servicer handles. It counts the applications and loans that a lender reports each year. Thus this site shows no per-size rate for this company.

More questions

How many complaints arrived in the last 30 days and the last 90 days?
16 complaints about Fay Servicing, LLC arrived in the 30 days to 16 Nov 2026. 85 complaints arrived in the 90 days to 16 Nov 2026. The CFPB publishes a complaint when the company responds or after 15 days. Thus the counts of the newest weeks can still increase.
What share of the closed complaints ended with relief?
Of the closed complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026, 0% are Closed with monetary relief or Closed with non-monetary relief. 0% of all the complaints in the period are Closed with monetary relief.
In which states do the consumers live?
Consumers in New York sent 12% of the complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026. Consumers in Texas sent 10.7% of the complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026. Consumers in California sent 10.7% of the complaints in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026. The complaints come from 42 of the 50 states and the District of Columbia.
Which other issues did consumers select in the 12 months to 16 Nov 2026?
Consumers selected the issue Struggling to pay mortgage for 32.7% of the complaints. Consumers selected the issue Incorrect information on your report for 8.7% of the complaints.